Wednesday, August 29, 2012

White people in Africa

I have some pretty strong, pretty emotional, and sometimes pretty convoluted thoughts about this.  (And I realize my title is blighted by broadness and bluntness that go both ways: Africa, obviously, is a vastly diverse continent, and white people certainly have all manner of diverse reasons for being in Africa, including having been born there.  But sometimes I think generalizations are more expressive than political correctness.)  So rather than offer a tirade or lengthy exposition, all I'd like to do for now is offer a little intro and share an article that may add a new dimension in your thinking about what Africa is, and what it means, especially when you're the one living there.

I'm tired of hearing people talk about "how happy" people they meet in Africa--or Haiti, or South America, or wherever they've recently come back from spending a week or two--are, "even though they are so poor." Yes, there is material poverty of a different flavor in these places (for simplicity's sake, let's term them the "Global South," since I'm not big in a developed/developing dichotomy) when compared to the United States.  Yes, I've met plenty of happy people in Ghana, Uganda, and Haiti, and many of these people are indeed very materially poor.  And yes, it is definitely a good and humbling thing for me to be reminded on my visits there of just how many things I assume are at least normal, if not essential, for life are actually just obfuscating luxuries that distract from some of the realities of life I'd rather not face.

But it's too easy to release ourselves from responsibility, much less ask ourselves if we in fact do have a responsibility, much less give careful consideration to how we should respond to this maybe-responsibility, by telling ourselves that, well, it's a shame that my friend can't buy food this week because the government decided not to pay rural teachers on time, or that a 10-year-old can't have an asphyxiating tumor removed because government health insurance doesn't cover for surgery and there's no private health insurance in Ghana, but at least they're happy in the midst of their poverty.  To an extent, maybe there is a sort of Pauline contentment going on here: "I know what it is to be in need, and I know what it is to have plenty.  I have learned the secret of being content in any and every situation, whether well fed or hungry, whether living in plenty or in want" (Philippians 4:12).  Or maybe not.  So, even though one journalist's account of his experiences is not authoritative for a nation, I don't think we white Americans (yes, "we," including me!) get to pick which is the answer.

So, too much exposition already, but here's the article:

Thoughts?

Sunday, August 26, 2012

the things u promise sometime ago

I mentioned in passing a little while back that I should address the idea of obligation at some point... so here goes:

Last spring I struggled a lot with what it means to love people--fully and really, and even when that means not giving them what they want, and even when what they want is you and time with you.  Oh God!--That's painful.  I really want to love people, but let's be honest: my love never saved anyone, ever, so as much as I yearn to be present to and care for people, I have to remember that it is Jesus' love is preeminent, and that my attempts to love can go too far.  (And sometimes, rather than failing by trying to be more than I can for someone, I run the opposite way and am downright unloving in my own selfishness.)  Love is confusing.
This is how we know what love is: Jesus Christ laid down his life for us.  And we ought to lay down our lives for our brothers and sisters.  If anyone has material possessions and sees a brother or sister in need but has no pity on them, how can the love of God be in that person?  Dear children, let us not love with words or speech but with actions and in truth. -- 1 John 3:16-18 
How much should we lay down our lives?  Laying ourselves down doesn't mean, I don't think, being totally available to everyone at all times; Jesus, for His part, withdrew to a quiet place many times when there were still huge crowds pressing in around Him.  Is pity really enough?  Because when Jesus was moved with pity, He was also moved, as in to heal or provide food or something.  Or is it more about giving possessions away and not being selfish?  Certainly enough of Jesus' teaching is dedicated to dealing with people who love their possessions more than Him and His people.  But what actions are loving?  What does it mean to love in truth?

There's a small, simple notebook I keep of sermon notes, prayer requests, testimonies, revelations during Bible reading, the ways in which I feel God speaking to me and directing my path in specific moments, and sometimes just desperate prayers.  I wrote in it when I started having this love conundrum.  Perhaps to illuminate how overwhelming it is when people want more of me than I can give, and how confounding it is sometimes that anyone thinks I have much good in me to offer them, I'll share my entry from 28 March 2012:
Oh God.
People are looking for Jesus and they find me.  God!  Help me point them to Jesus.  I'm falling flat on my face. 
I think a little clarification is useful here.  Firstly, I don't think I have nothing to offer relationally, or that it's anomalous that anyone would want to be my friend, or that I don't have fulfilling friendships.  But what I do know, and cling to, is that if there is anything beautiful in me, and I believe there is, it is there because the Holy Spirit made it grow there and because I'm made in God's lovely image.  Secondly, nothing about Jessica can fulfill anyone, but the closer I grow to Jesus, the more I look like Him.  I think the best explanation of why I found myself overwhelmed, feeling like people expected things from me that I could not give them, is that I must have looked enough like Jesus to have been attractive.  Thirdly, I fall flat on my face--every time!--trying to be more to people than I can be, trying to take on others' weariness when it's clear that it's in Jesus, not me, that people can find rest for their souls, and that it's his yolk, not mine, that's easy.  (Fourthly, let it also be known that, in spite of all this, I value human relationships very highly, and affirm wholeheartedly that God created humans as relational beings and that faith is to be pursued in community.)

God answers prayers, usually in unexpected ways, and this was no exception.  The day after I scrawled that desperate little prayer in my notebook, I felt God revealed to me something new; it was like He spoke it to me while I was praying.  On 29 March, I recorded:
When Jesus paid my debt, He paid it all.  I don't owe anyone anything.  At all.
There is a certain perverse understanding of love in which we're constantly trying to pay everyone back.  It's a well-known and widely accepted anthropological theory that gift-giving is in fact just a subset of exchange relationships.  A sense of indebtedness and obligation can be fostered by many things, among them another's actions (the feeling you should reciprocate someone's kind gesture), or another's need (someone needs something that you have, so you feel you should give it).

It's like the agonizing process of making out your childhood birthday invitation list when you're trying to decide if you have to invite the annoying kid in your 3rd grade class just because she invited you to her birthday party the month before.  Are you expected to?  Well, probably, at least by your classmate.  Are you obliged?  No, certainly not.  But might you feel like you are (at least if you're a particularly emotionally sensitive 8-year-old)?  I can't speak for you, but for me the answer is resoundingly "yes"...  This has been something like the background music of my life.  So the idea of not owing people things is radical to me.  But it's also amazing, and liberating--it is for freedom we've been set free, not to be burdened again by a yolk of slavery (Galatians 5:1)--even slavery to others' expectations!  Because Jesus cashed the check for my wages of death, I'm free (Romans 6:23)--and I cannot claim credit (Ephesians 2:8-10) or pay back this debt.  Therefore, I don't respond to Jesus' gift of Himself out of obligation (I actually think trying to pay Jesus back would be sinfully prideful, as if I could equate my sacrifices with His ultimate sacrifice), but rather out of--wait for it--LOVE.  So here we are again.

But this explication of love and debt has mostly been a prelude to what I want to share, that is, a four-part text message I got this afternoon from Nana Sarfo, the chief of Naama, a village nearby Asaam.  After learning that the midwife with whom I was supposed to be working was essentially on medical leave for my entire 5 weeks in Ghana, Nana Sarfo accompanied me on a series of visits to the Mampong regional hospital and the hospital in nearby Kofiase, hoping to gain permission to shadow and research in Kofiase but ultimately gaining nothing more than a lot of dust on our feet and a close-up view of bureaucracy.  Here's the transcript of the text:
Hello akua Afriyie,how are you doing? You are doing great by God's grace.please another batch of SIT [study abroad students] are coming to Ghana this september so i would like to know whether you can get in touch with them,i mean those around your area so that contact them and give them the things u promise sometime ago.my secretary's email is ********@yahoo.com or facebook.i would be grateful if u could give me your email or facebook address.thank YOU goodbye.Nana sarfo Adu-Naama Ashanti
I've been long-winded already, and I'm slowing down, but here's where I've been getting: I remember many conversations with Nana (the name means grandpa or grandma, and is the title of all Ashanti chiefs) about the past study abroad students who came to visit.  Some of them had built a solar panel station for the village to stabilize their electricity; another group had dug a borehole to provide clean drinking water; and one of his particular favorites had bought him a laptop computer, sending it to him by way of the next crop of Naama-bound SIT study abroad students.  He carefully scrolled through each of the contacts in his cell phone, pleased to tell me when each of the Americans had come, and what they studied, and whether they stayed in his compound or nearby.

He'd often remind me of the borehole and the laptop and the solar panels when I'd thank him after yet another fruitless, cramped taxi ride between Asaam and Kofiase and Mampong.  He'd pay the fare and tell me that when I got home I should tell my father about the way he'd taken care of me by accompanying me on these trips, and that when I bought him a gift I could send it with the next batch of SIT students.

And there are others: The pastor of the tiny Asaam Presbyterian Church who wants me to send money for the congregation to build a church on the plot of land they somehow scraped enough money together to buy years ago, but that has sat fallow for so long weeds seem to have squelched the decaying foundation into submission.  The physician's assistant at the Asaam Health Clinic who wants me to apply to an American college on behalf of his daughter so she can study nursing, mostly unaware of the exorbitant expenses and the complicated application and the necessity of the SAT.  The fellow teacher and friend from my Bridge Year who will expect me to contact my fellow Bridge Year students to cobble together the $450 that will pay his school fees for next year, since we've already set that precedent this year.

It makes me weary.

It makes me angry at all the other white people who have traveled to Africa, seen poverty, cuddled some dirty-but-adorable kids as their unbelievably-poor-but-still-so-you-know-happy families stand around nearby, and whipped out their figurative checkbooks to make it all better before going back home to their cable TV and all-you-can-eat buffets.

Sometimes it makes me wish I had a checkbook like that so I could whip it out too.

It makes me want to explain the cost of living (and of college!  and med school!  and shipping!) in the US, sort of to justify it to myself that I haven't bought a laptop or a borehole or a field of solar panels.

It makes me wonder what Nana Sarfo thinks I "promise sometime ago" to give him, since I never told him that I'd buy him anything.

And it makes me wonder if this obligation-free life is tenable outside an abstractly theological realm.



This is probably why I was never supposed to give my phone number out in the first place.  Forget that; I'm frustrated and uncertain and glad that I did.  Love is confusing.

Sunday, August 19, 2012

It Is Well

(link)

My sin--not in part, but the whole--
Has been nailed to the cross
So I bear it no more
Praise the Lord, praise the Lord, O my soul

Saturday, August 18, 2012

August Books

I have this habit of picking up books wherever they're lying around and starting to read them, sometimes in the beginning, but sometimes not, without really making a commitment to finish reading them.  I'm just not one of those people who has to finish a book after I've begun, unless maybe it's really good.  So here I present a list (in no particular order) of the books--two of which I've finished, three of which I've started this month, three of which I first began between 6 months and 2 years ago, and one of which has been a friend for quite some time--I'm hoping to read this month.  I'll try to give you an update on how everything goes... (and maybe this will help :) )

1) Pursuing God's Will Together: A Discernment Practice for Leadership Groups by Ruth Haley Barton
This book met me, challenged me, and offered practical perspectives on some deep longings and questions I've been struggling with this summer regarding how to discern God's voice, and how to follow the Holy Spirit's leading not just as an individual, but as part of a body.  On a side note, the author is my dear aunt :)


2) Renovation of the Church: What Happens When a Seeker Church Discovers Spiritual Formation by Kent Carlson and Mike Leuken
So far, so good, though I'm not done yet.  I've enjoyed seeing how God prompted the authors of this book to completely reorient the focus of their church; though at times it's lacking specifics, I've been encouraged by this testimony of God's guidance and grace.


3) A Heart for the Work: Journeys Through an African Medical School by Claire Wendland
I should have finished this long before summer began because it was assigned reading for my Medical Anthropology class in the spring, but in the heat of the semester I didn't give it the attention it deserved. Better late than never?  Inspiring so far, and a very insightful blend of anthropological analysis and a gentle exploration of simple human relationships and experience.


4) A Hope in the Unseen: An American Odyssey from the Inner City to the Ivy League by Ron Suskind
Required reading for incoming Residential College Advisers (and Assistants/Alternates, like me!).  The main character, Cedric, is one of the most raw, unapologetic participant-observers I've ever read.  Not to mention I was left with much to reflect on, many blessings to be thankful for, and an unexpected instance or two of identification with Cedric.


5) Christ & Culture by H. Richard Niebuhr
... since Ravonne lent it to me almost a year ago and I haven't finished yet!  (For shame.)  But so far, an interesting and useful explication of secular perceptions of culture.  I'm excited to finish because the title leads me to believe that it should be required reading for Anthropologically-inclined Christians.


6) Reclaiming the Body: Christians and the Faithful Use of Modern Medicine by Joel Shuman and Brian Volck, MD
Hopefully the title says most of it; I'm not too far into it yet, but my mom bought it for me (thanks!) and I am certainly not planning to leave Jesus out of my future medical pursuits--particularly because it's He who led me to pursue those pursuits in the first place--so it should be a good'n.


7) Letters to a Young Calvinist: An Invitation to the Reformed Tradition by James K. A. Smith
Another one of those that's been sitting around awhile, having been left in limbo, it was a gift from my parents when I decided to check out Pentapresbycostaterianism, a.k.a. remembering that the Holy Spirit is an actual, real, live, active Person while not forgetting that God's main mission is not to make everything cushy for me here on Earth.


8) Organic Chemistry by Thomas Sorrell
Just kidding.  Mostly.


9) The Bible by God
I'm very behind on my 3-month reading plan, and my prayer is to love the Word, not just get through because I made it a goal... Finding the path of discipline that doesn't cross into obsessive, Pharisaic rule-keeping while not just giving myself a free pass of laziness.

Friday, August 3, 2012

You are holy.

(link)

Abba, how I forget.  Forget this, any and all of it, unless I commit all of it to You.  I have been foolishly, willfully selfish recently, I just want to be back with You without me in the way.

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Relational Responsibility

I was in the middle of a run this afternoon (on a treadmill--you know it's August when the Midwest is hotter than West Africa) when a number with a familiar country code flashed on my cell phone screen.  It was Victor, the Roman Father of the village of Asaam, where I spent a month working at the Asaam Health Center, just calling to say hello, so I paused my workout and we chatted for a minute and before he hung up.  A few minutes later, another call came in, also from +233, but before I could pick it up my phone stopped ringing.  I had been flashed--a term that is initially disorienting to Americans but is completely innocuous and means, at least in Ghana, that someone has called you long enough for you to see they've called but that they've hung up before  you can pick up.  They have "flashed" you.  This indicates that you should call the original caller back, since presumably you have phone credit to spare and although all incoming calls are free, you'll pay per minute for each call you make.  Without widespread voicemail and with very few things (including attending church or a funeral, or having a face-to-face conversation) that take precedence over an incoming call, once you've been flashed, you're pretty much expected to call back in a few minutes, otherwise you're likely to be flashed again.  Not having rushed upstairs to look at my notebook of Ghanaian phone numbers and find my international calling card in the middle of my workout, I heard my phone ring at 2:55, and 2:58, and 3:05.  

The first time I went to Ghana, I went with several warnings: no greeting or eating or paying or receiving with the left hand, remember to take your malaria prophylaxis, and don't give out your home phone number.  I made sure to hold whatever I was carrying with my left hand to prevent any mishaps, gave my tall bottle of pills a prominent spot on my floor so I'd be forced to see it each morning, and became quite adept at explaining that, no, I couldn't give my US number because, you see, when I get back I'll have to get a new phone, so I don't know what the number will be yet, but how about you give me your number and then I can call you and give it to you once I have my new phone.  Not so bad.  I only broke the last rule with four of the many people I met over those 9 months (two of whom were my program directors and one of whom was my host mother, for goodness' sake), and that calculated lapse resulted in a phone call every three or four weeks--comfortable, and nice for keeping up my Twi besides.

All that caution went out the window this time.  Within a month, I managed to give my American cell phone number out to at least 15 people, a clear break from my previous digital stinginess.  

By now I've been away from Ghana for almost a full week, and back home in the Midwest for five days.  And my cell phone call log looks quite a bit different than it ever has, including the week after I got back from Ghana round one.  When I reached home July 28, I put my international phone card through an intense workout, using it to place 17 calls--"Akua, woaduru ho?"  "Onyame adom, aane, afe na maduru fie nti mafr3 wo aka kyer3 wo"/"Jessica, have you arrived?" "Yes, by God's grace, I just got home so I'm calling to let you know."  And since then, of the 35 calls I have received, 26 of them have been preceded by +233 and several of the remaining calls have been from a woman I met on the flight from Accra to Casablanca and then helped to catch the Amtrak from New York to DC.  

And then there was that third call from +233 at 3:05 this afternoon.  It was Alice, I figured, a fiery and boisterous (and, according to some of the disapproving adults in the village, somewhat disrespectful in her audacity) soon-to-be-7th grader from Asaam, who during the course of a month of casual friendship had explained to me her very literal definition of teenage pregnancy (i.e., that it would be fine if I were to get pregnant, despite the fact that I'm not married, because I'm 21 and therefore no longer a teenager, while a 19-year-old who got pregnant would be contributing to a societal vice); insisted that she was not an "obibini," an African/black person, but rather "kokoo," or red, despite the fact she shared her complexion with her family, whom she dubbed abibifo), Africans/black people; convinced me that she was a Presbyterian so that she should go to church with me despite the fact that she'd always gone to the Methodist church across the road; and told me that I was unlike any of the whites who had come to stay in Asaam for brief research stints a few years ago because 1) I speak Twi, 2) I know how to do my laundry by hand, and 3) I know how to greet so I'm not self-absorbed.


Alice.  I'd talked with her the day before yesterday, and she'd promised to call me yesterday, which she had done (if you count flashing me as calling me, which I guess I will).  We said a lot of the same things over and over, that everyone in Asaam including her family is fine, that everyone in Wisconsin including my family is fine, that she's missed me, that I've missed her, and 10 minutes later hung up.  And when she called me today, I didn't quite know what to do, because I was starting to feel like maybe 15 people was a few too many.  Because those 15 people aren't just people who randomly have my American phone number; they are 15 people with whom I built relationships.  I bought bread or apples (imported from South Africa, and conveniently available from a hawker through the window of your tro-tro, provided you don't try to pay with your left hand) or chocolate (I've heard rumors that you can buy chocolate in Kofiase, the town about 15 minutes down the road, but certainly not in Asaam) or Don Simon or ripe plantains (it was early in the season, but I snagged some in Effiduase since there weren't any in Asaam, or Kofiase or Mampong for that matter) or whatever was requested by these people, these friends, on the few times I went to town.  And on more than a few occasions I was given raw peanuts, fresh corn, a pile of yams, or some cocoyams to take home for my mother by these same friends.  

See, relationships are complicated, and the funny thing is, as much as we curious oborunis (foreigners/white people) like to remember with fondness all the cute babies we got to see at the clinic where we were working or how quaint those days when we had to do our laundry by hand were, I think we like to forget relationships.  It's usually easier to remember our time as visitors in other cultures in strokes of static, remembered relationships--or at least not to let the vibrant streaks of dynamic relationships interfere too much with the tidy picture we'd like to paint about our experiences with people in AN AFRICAN VILLAGE.  About our one FRIEND WHO CALLS US FROM AFRICA so we can practice speaking THE LOCAL LANGUAGE and the rest who we've sort of forgotten.  We emphasize the parts that make us look like good, compassionate volunteers and humanitarians, and are prone to whittling the rest (including people) down into sound bytes that curious people back home can digest.  In the world of international friends, one is comfortable, and predictable: a phone call every three or four weeks; 15 doesn't let you forget, and refuses to be made into a neatly packaged sound byte.

Of course every relationship that you begin cannot be sustained, at least not at the level of friendship (which, despite the fact that many Ghanaians "afa m'adamfo"/"have taken me as a friend," is a pretty intense commitment, as a very dear friend has reminded me).  

I stumbled across this quotation from an article about a Princeton grad, Shivani Sud '12, who won a fellowship to work in India next year.  Perhaps what I've written thus far has been colluded by the emotions of coming back home when I'm not quite sure whether I'd rather still be in Asaam, so if it is, perhaps this will help to clarify my intentions for writing:
While interviewing a female patient, the woman told Sud that academics and government workers often come to her community and take a lot of notes, only to leave after the obtain the information they need for research purposes.
Boom, our indictment: Using relationships when they suit us, and throwing them away when they don't.  Taking lots of notes and leaving lots of unfulfilled relational expectations.  (Sorry for all the parenthetical clauses, but no this is a complex thought in my head and there are no footnotes for blog posts, so, to clarify... I know that expectations are not obligations.  And I don't much believe in obligations, anyway, but that's for another post.  But I think expectations, if not met, should at least be acknowledged between the parties whose relationship has created expectation, and certainly not ignored.)  Honestly, this is why it quietly pleases me to hear from Alice that I am different from the other oborunis who have come to Asaam: I hope she is right, and that what Shivani Sud's interviewee has experienced will not mark the way I move about in and engage with other cultures. 

One of my best friends, in a hurried (did you know it's more than 3x more expensive to call Tanzania than the US from Ghana??  I didn't either...) conversation a few weeks ago--ironically, about some money matters related to a mutual friend from Ghana, where we did the Bridge Year Program together a couple of years ago--, mentioned that she feels she might have made a mistake in the way she handled relationships while studying Swahili in Tanzania this summer.  She speculated that by worrying so much about failing to keep up her end of relationships with Tanzanian friends after returning home to the US, she pushed almost everyone away without giving much space for even a fledgling relationship.  And we agreed that by all means, yes, she may have mishandled the opportunity to forge relationships.  But we've both seen enough pictures of American college kids hamming it up on camera with some African friends whose names they'll soon forget in the name of having a great Facebook picture that I think we're right to be wary about how we conduct relationships--after all, we don't excuse ourselves from Facebook temptation.  Especially now that, after our respective leaves of absence, we're back online in hopes of doing better to keep in touch with friends far afield.

I don't know what I'll do when Alice calls again tomorrow, as I'm sure she will.  I expect I'll call her back, and she'll ask how the people of Wisconsin and my family are, and I'll ask how the people of Asaam and her family are, and she'll say she misses me, and I'll say I miss her, and we'll hang up.  But it will be more than that, too, at least more than those words.  Because as silly as it seems for a college kid thousands of miles away from a tiny village that most Ghanaians have never heard of to keep in touch with a middle school student who lives there, I am going to try as I wrestle out this question: What does it mean to be responsible in these relationships?

To close, let me send a shout-out to my new, true friends Evelyn and Gloria.  Now that I'm home in Wisconsin, we don't get to be home in Asaam together, cooking together, washing Evelyn's laundry together,  eating together "abom," laughing together about how often I say, "3firi s3..."/"because...".  But I've promised that when I get married someday, they'll be invited, and I'm quite looking forward to our future reunion, by God's grace, "daakye, Onyame adom."


God, make me a good steward.